CRASH LAB

Home / Process / Case 08

Case 08 of 18 · CINEOSIS

Handmade CINEOSIS

If every pose is keyed by hand, can every sign read in real footage?

79 hand-authored passages for the 39 signs outside the pilot, plus the six pilot passages: 85 passages, 21.8 minutes.

145 sheets · Oct 18 00:23 to Oct 18 07:27

How it was made

  1. Plates stay unaltered archival clips; they may be slowed, retimed or cropped, never painted.
  2. Every pose is keyed by hand in code: key poses, contacts, timing.
  3. Each review agent describes what it sees before it reads what was intended.

What this case teaches

  1. Blind first, then intent, separates two questions: does it read, and does it read as the sign? Round 4: 17 read fully, but only 13 matched intent.
  2. Round 2 produced a shared integration standard (contact shadow, cast shadow, tone mapping, grain) that every passage then carries.
  3. The record says what has not been reviewed. That list is as much a part of the work as the verdicts.

How it differs. The atlas asked a machine to place Bola. Here a person places her every time, and the critic process is the main tool.

What broke and what changed

  • Props too small to read: a footprint, crumbs, copies.Props drawn larger and held longer.
  • Shadows pointing the wrong way.Shadow direction taken from the plate's key light.
  • Cause after effect: stamps, a dive, a jump.Retimed so the action lands before the response.
  • Figure too small in the frame.Push-ins on seven passages.

First sheet and last sheet

Where the stage started and where it finished.

Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:23
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 07:27

The sheets, step by step

Grouped by working session. Click any sheet to view it full size; use the arrow keys to move through them.

Step 1Critic: handmade passage and Test framesOct 18 00:23–00:43 · 14 sheets
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:23
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:28
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:32
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:34
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0Oct 18 00:43
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1Oct 18 00:43
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2Oct 18 00:43
Step 2Test frames and Critic: handmade passageOct 18 00:43–01:39 · 12 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0Oct 18 00:43
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1Oct 18 00:43
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2Oct 18 00:44
Show 8 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0Oct 18 00:44
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:44
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:44
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 00:57
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 01:12
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 01:24
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 01:25
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 01:39
Step 3Contact sheet and Critic: handmade passageOct 18 02:06–02:25 · 14 sheets
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:06
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:18
Contact sheet 2
Contact sheet 2Oct 18 02:22
Contact sheet 4
Contact sheet 4Oct 18 02:22
Show 10 more from this step
Contact sheet 5
Contact sheet 5Oct 18 02:23
Contact sheet 6
Contact sheet 6Oct 18 02:23
Contact sheet 7
Contact sheet 7Oct 18 02:23
Contact sheet 8
Contact sheet 8Oct 18 02:23
Contact sheet 9
Contact sheet 9Oct 18 02:23
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1Oct 18 02:25
Step 4Critic: handmade passage and Critic: x5Oct 18 02:25–02:26 · 14 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.4Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.2Oct 18 02:25
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.0Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.5
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.5Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.2Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.1Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.0Oct 18 02:25
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.1Oct 18 02:25
Critic: x3 0 full
Critic: x3 0 fullOct 18 02:26
Critic: x4 0 crop
Critic: x4 0 cropOct 18 02:26
Critic: x5 4 crop
Critic: x5 4 cropOct 18 02:26
Critic: x5 2 crop
Critic: x5 2 cropOct 18 02:26
Step 5Test frames and Critic: x7Oct 18 02:26–02:57 · 14 sheets
Critic: x5 2 crop0
Critic: x5 2 crop0Oct 18 02:26
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:27
Critic: x7 2 crop
Critic: x7 2 cropOct 18 02:27
Critic: x7 1 crop
Critic: x7 1 cropOct 18 02:27
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: x8 1 crop
Critic: x8 1 cropOct 18 02:27
Critic: x8 0 crop
Critic: x8 0 cropOct 18 02:27
Critic: x1 2 full
Critic: x1 2 fullOct 18 02:27
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:43
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:44
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:51
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:53
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:54
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:56
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 02:57
Step 6Test framesOct 18 03:00 · 1 sheet
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 03:00
Step 7Critic: handmade passageOct 18 03:57–03:58 · 14 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 10.3
Critic: handmade passage, sign 10.3Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 10.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 10.4Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 11.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 11.0Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 11.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 11.4Oct 18 03:57
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 12.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 12.0Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 12.3
Critic: handmade passage, sign 12.3Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.1Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.2Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.1Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 1.2Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.0Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 3.1Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.0Oct 18 03:57
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 4.2Oct 18 03:58
Step 8Critic: handmade passageOct 18 03:58 · 10 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.2Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 5.4Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.0Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.5
Critic: handmade passage, sign 6.5Oct 18 03:58
Show 6 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.1Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 7.2Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.0Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 8.1Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 9.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 9.2Oct 18 03:58
Critic: handmade passage, sign 9.3
Critic: handmade passage, sign 9.3Oct 18 03:58
Step 9Test framesOct 18 04:27–04:44 · 2 sheets
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 04:27
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 04:44
Step 10X11Oct 18 05:17 · 2 sheets
x11 4 s
x11 4 sOct 18 05:17
x11 0 s
x11 0 sOct 18 05:17
Step 11Critic: handmade passageOct 18 05:44–05:45 · 14 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.1Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 13.2Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 14.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 14.0Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 14.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 14.1Oct 18 05:44
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 15.3
Critic: handmade passage, sign 15.3Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 15.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 15.4Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 16.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 16.0Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 16.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 16.2Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 17.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 17.1Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 18.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 18.0Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 18.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 18.4Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 19.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 19.0Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 19.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 19.1Oct 18 05:44
Critic: handmade passage, sign 20.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 20.1Oct 18 05:45
Step 12Critic: handmade passageOct 18 05:45 · 14 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 20.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 20.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 21.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 21.1Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 21.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 21.4Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 22.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 22.0Oct 18 05:45
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 22.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 22.4Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 23.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 23.0Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 23.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 23.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 24.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 24.1Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 24.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 24.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 25.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 25.0Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 25.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 25.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 26.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 26.1Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 26.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 26.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 27.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 27.0Oct 18 05:45
Step 13Critic: handmade passage and Test framesOct 18 05:45 · 14 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 27.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 27.4Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 30.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 30.0Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 30.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 30.1Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 31.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 31.2Oct 18 05:45
Show 10 more from this step
Critic: handmade passage, sign 31.5
Critic: handmade passage, sign 31.5Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 32.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 32.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 32.3
Critic: handmade passage, sign 32.3Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 33.4
Critic: handmade passage, sign 33.4Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 33.5
Critic: handmade passage, sign 33.5Oct 18 05:45
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 35.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 35.0Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 35.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 35.1Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 36.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 36.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 37.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 37.2Oct 18 05:45
Step 14Critic: handmade passageOct 18 05:45 · 4 sheets
Critic: handmade passage, sign 37.5
Critic: handmade passage, sign 37.5Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 40.2
Critic: handmade passage, sign 40.2Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 41.0
Critic: handmade passage, sign 41.0Oct 18 05:45
Critic: handmade passage, sign 41.1
Critic: handmade passage, sign 41.1Oct 18 05:45
Step 15Test framesOct 18 06:09 · 1 sheet
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 06:09
Step 16Test framesOct 18 07:27 · 1 sheet
Test frames
Test framesOct 18 07:27

What came out of it

CIN-04 21:46CINEOSIS · handmadeEvery sign authored by hand over unaltered archive clips, two passages per sign, each reviewed blind by a fresh critic. CIN-06 0:51 · reelHandmade · first batchThe first hand-authored passages, before the first blind review. CIN-07 3:30 · reelHandmade · signs 1–8Review reel of the handmade passages for signs 1 to 8. CIN-08 11:57 · reelHandmade · signs 13–41Review reel of the handmade passages for signs 13 to 41.

Read the record

Carried forward

The critic process becomes a character in its own right.