{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"uncertain","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":"unknown","unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=unknown","constraint_unknown:recognition_classifier","primary_quality_bar_not_met"],"status":"milestone_needs_review","train_eligible":false},"id":"45ac0bc9ef35d8f4941511e0a1b0c8e995482c2e8356e91ec21f988e22e05ecd","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"add_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v1/"],"before_refs":["design.png"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"Source-linked phase distinction is too subtle to judge confidently from the six still keys.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Exact angular funnel construction","Sparse original black-line identity","Source-specific road and utility-pole setting"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"uncertain"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["keys/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum recall; parts_kept must equal1 per key","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.997427652733119}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":null,"revision":"tornado-v1","source":{"identity":"b615f6f9-22b3-571b-bbb6-0739a4f7cf1d","interval":{"end":3.2699333333,"start":0.2335666667,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":"unknown","train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","sequence":1}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","source_pose","source_composition"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","mask_fit","normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"5c4e7cea92e55453f4f58b92ab29642116aed666724aa68d1df10b2ab213e835","input":{"action":{"details":"Six source-observed native-stroke keys and 73-frame layered review assembly.","type":"add_key"},"after_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v1/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["keys/"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"The sharp, narrow lower cone overstates the source column taper and exposed tip.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original doodle rim and overlapping top strokes","Sparse angular linework and consistent drawing identity across all six samples","Central placement beyond the street, flanking tree masses, and right-side pole/wire arrangement","Restrained palette and foreground/background hierarchy"],"scope":["drawing_identity","source_pose","source_composition"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/review-v1.json","integrated/revisions/v1/assembly-checks.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/traced.json"],"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.9993817619783617},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"mask_fit","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json","integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg"],"parent":"tornado-v1","revision":"tornado-integrated-v1","source":{"identity":"b615f6f9-22b3-571b-bbb6-0739a4f7cf1d","interval":{"end":3.2699333333,"start":0.2335666667,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"45ac0bc9ef35d8f4941511e0a1b0c8e995482c2e8356e91ec21f988e22e05ecd","sequence":2}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses","source_composition"],"critic_verdict":"bar_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["foot_slide_zero_intervals"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":"unknown","unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","mask_fit","normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["constraint_failed:foot_slide_zero_intervals"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"e812894796c14849a93707f60a7da2769b06dd60460d640259513fa81f7ad06e","input":{"action":{"details":"Bounded lower-third repair of native side strokes: modest widening and terminal-point foreground occlusion; preserved original three-stroke construction, source-specific street/tree/pole placement, no invented spin.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["integrated/shot.json","integrated/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v1/comparison.mp4"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"No remaining still-pose gap named. Normal-speed playback not watched; timing, continuity and motion unapproved.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Uneven open spiral rim, projecting upper stroke, long left taper and kinked right contour","Spare irregular native linework","Source pole/wire placement and tree-framed funnel"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses","source_composition"],"verdict":"bar_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v2.json","integrated/assembly-checks.json","integrated/video-validation.json","integrated/sam/provenance.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/traced.json"],"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":1.0},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"mask_fit","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"foot_slide_zero_intervals","status":"fail","unit":"observed planted intervals","value":0},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/video-validation.json"],"name":"complete_video_decode","status":"pass","unit":"frames per movie","value":73}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json","integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg"],"parent":"tornado-integrated-v1","revision":"tornado-integrated-v2","source":{"identity":"b615f6f9-22b3-571b-bbb6-0739a4f7cf1d","interval":{"end":3.2699333333,"start":0.2335666667,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":"unknown","train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"5c4e7cea92e55453f4f58b92ab29642116aed666724aa68d1df10b2ab213e835","sequence":3}