{
  "bar_met": false,
  "verdict": "The original nine-stroke rain doodle remains recognizable, and the bridge, converging rails, roadside poles and wet-road ripple marks identify the source scene. The framing bar is not met: the source's bridge horizon stays near the same height across the interval, while the integrated scene moves substantially downward, leaving progressively less road visible.",
  "one_gap_that_matters_most": "Unmotivated vertical drift of the source-derived scene. In key-01 the road horizon is around y=204; by key-08 it is around y=315, although the paired source frames keep it around y=200. This changes the framing and reduces the visible surface where the rain event occurs.",
  "smallest_repair": "Hold the bridge, horizon, rails and roadside landmarks at their initial source-aligned vertical positions throughout the shot; retain motion in the falling doodle strokes and road impact marks. No new drawing style is needed.",
  "must_not_be_lost": "Keep the spare uneven black rain strokes, including the distinctive kinked drops, and their recognizable arrangement and proportions. Preserve the thin simple bridge perspective and restrained impact ellipses, which connect those strokes to the source event without repainting the doodle.",
  "source_event_assessment": "The sampled source shows continuous rain onto a wet bridge road with visible surface disturbance and stable perspective. The keys represent falling rain and some road impacts, but the scene drift weakens their connection to that stable source framing.",
  "identity_assessment": "Same original doodle identity is visibly retained in the long, sparse, slightly slanted or bent black stroke family. Added scene lines are lighter and thinner, so the rain strokes remain distinguishable.",
  "visually_viewed": [
    "integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg",
    "integrated/design.png",
    "integrated/source-01.jpg", "integrated/key-01.png",
    "integrated/source-02.jpg", "integrated/key-02.png",
    "integrated/source-03.jpg", "integrated/key-03.png",
    "integrated/source-04.jpg", "integrated/key-04.png",
    "integrated/source-05.jpg", "integrated/key-05.png",
    "integrated/source-06.jpg", "integrated/key-06.png",
    "integrated/source-07.jpg", "integrated/key-07.png",
    "integrated/source-08.jpg", "integrated/key-08.png"
  ],
  "metadata_read": "shots/rain/source.json; clip-relative interval 34.4344344344–38.8054721388 seconds",
  "actual_normal_speed_playback_occurred": false,
  "motion_review_limit": "comparison.mp4 was supplied but was not visually played. This verdict compares the supplied ordered stills; it does not certify cadence, continuity between keys, or normal-speed motion quality."
}