{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","trace_fidelity"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"e2c5b55885a28066d604d6bbf85e9acdeb93944fea458b93af257652e2fd56c3","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"add_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v1/"],"before_refs":["design.png"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"The abdomen pitch change between source keys 2 and 3 is flattened out.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Exact triangular abdomen and unusually tall open wing silhouette","Polygonal unfilled head and original bent appendages","Sparse uneven black strokes and absence of added insect detail","Existing raised and bent foreleg poses"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":null,"revision":"mosquito-v1","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","sequence":1}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"uncertain","drawing_identity_preserved":"unknown","failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":"unknown","unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=unknown","drawing_identity_preserved=unknown","constraint_unknown:recognition_classifier","primary_quality_bar_not_met"],"status":"milestone_needs_review","train_eligible":false},"id":"ab87ef7178866bd2d68f7fb71db5a64821c250660735a163c59814d367a67f02","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v2/"],"before_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original tall wing and hooked head strokes","Small source-related abdomen and leg changes without redesign"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"uncertain"},"drawing_identity_preserved":"unknown","evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v2.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["keys/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum recall; parts_kept must equal1 per key","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.9987808932727474}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":"mosquito-v1","revision":"mosquito-v2","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":"unknown","train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"e2c5b55885a28066d604d6bbf85e9acdeb93944fea458b93af257652e2fd56c3","sequence":2}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":true,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier"]},"reasons":["constraint_unknown:recognition_classifier"],"status":"milestone_needs_review","train_eligible":false},"id":"556886153f96f2fda7529401a2b23f5b3dcac3ca8c9ae8225521a01b842edd35","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v2/"],"before_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original tall wing and hooked head strokes","Small source-related abdomen and leg changes without redesign"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v2.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["keys/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum recall; parts_kept must equal1 per key","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.9987808932727474}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":"mosquito-v2","revision":"mosquito-v2-review-normalization","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":true,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"ab87ef7178866bd2d68f7fb71db5a64821c250660735a163c59814d367a67f02","sequence":3}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["SAM_source_mask_fit"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","independent_normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:SAM_source_mask_fit"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"194bc04a15cc7330efa8be471c4a58d6b4f71cd8b65b4e1b223b562d6bbb1a4c","input":{"action":{"details":"Assemble native eight-stroke mosquito on source-framed skin and held hair plane; first source pose review finds dangling lower-body shape.","type":"change_layer"},"after_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v1/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["keys/key-01.png"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Dangling lower-body contour breaks compact resting source pose. Geometry audit identifies original hooked leg as source of that shape; native wing is above abdomen.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original eight-stroke identity","Left-facing scale and placement","Held source-framed skin surface"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v1.json","integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json"],"name":"SAM_source_mask_fit","status":"fail","unit":"IoU","value":0.1980726677686816},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"independent_normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-inspection.jpg","integrated/source-track.json"],"parent":"mosquito-v2-review-normalization","revision":"mosquito-integrated-v1","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"556886153f96f2fda7529401a2b23f5b3dcac3ca8c9ae8225521a01b842edd35","sequence":4}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":false,"failed_constraints":["SAM_source_mask_fit"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":"unknown","unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","independent_normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["drawing_identity_preserved=false","constraint_failed:SAM_source_mask_fit"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"b8958a8210c7bbeecb88bfb2d5788b61de44084e690448e655cfc84f076588ad","input":{"action":{"details":"Repose original leg strokes from source thorax to splayed skin contacts, keeping native wing folded and all eight stroke identities. Source pose review improves but wing identity is lost by affine flattening.","type":"repair_tracking"},"after_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v2/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Source poses broadly retained but original wing contour is flattened into horizontal slivers.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Source-framed body pitch","Grounded splayed legs","Held skin drawing"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":false,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v2.json","integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json"],"name":"SAM_source_mask_fit","status":"fail","unit":"IoU","value":0.21151764053523692},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/traced.json"],"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.9956989247311828},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"independent_normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-inspection.jpg","integrated/source-track.json"],"parent":"mosquito-integrated-v1","revision":"mosquito-integrated-v2","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":"unknown","train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"194bc04a15cc7330efa8be471c4a58d6b4f71cd8b65b4e1b223b562d6bbb1a4c","sequence":5}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["SAM_source_mask_fit","verified_planted_intervals"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","independent_normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:SAM_source_mask_fit","constraint_failed:verified_planted_intervals"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"e91d0c245212f9c4367bd7a00201c241fae627762cc171be2b7a450cbe0ca988","input":{"action":{"details":"Rigidly rotate/scale original wing into folded source direction instead of affineflattening, retaining native contour proportions. Stop after3reviews; late character registration remains wrong.","type":"repair_tracking"},"after_refs":["integrated/shot.json","integrated/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Late keys do not follow source upward-left displacement; insect15\u201325px down/right at480x360.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Native wing contour and angular character identity","Source abdomen pitch progression","Held skin framing and grounded leg vocabulary"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v3.json","integrated/shot.json","integrated/traced.json","integrated/video-validation.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/shot.json"],"name":"SAM_source_mask_fit","status":"fail","unit":"IoU","value":0.2196893813351909},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/traced.json"],"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"pass","unit":"fraction","value":0.9904559915164369},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/assembly-checks.json"],"name":"verified_planted_intervals","status":"fail","unit":"intervals","value":0},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"independent_normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-inspection.jpg","integrated/source-track.json"],"parent":"mosquito-integrated-v2","revision":"mosquito-integrated-v3","source":{"identity":"2c4a25eb-f161-59a4-b440-22d33025a497","interval":{"end":5.2385719052,"start":0.2335669002,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"b8958a8210c7bbeecb88bfb2d5788b61de44084e690448e655cfc84f076588ad","sequence":6}