{
  "review": "blind visual review v1",
  "bar_met": false,
  "source_framing": "Met in the inspected stills: the insect stays near the same upper-middle position, faces left, and sits against the same descending skin edge.",
  "source_pose": "Not met: the large outlined wing hangs conspicuously below the body, giving the cartoon a dangling silhouette where the source has a compact, low, rightward folded silhouette.",
  "same_doodle_identity": "Recognizable in its angular head, pointed body, thin uneven strokes, and bent appendages, but the prominent downward wing weakens the match to the original doodle's silhouette.",
  "one_gap_that_matters_most": "The wing placement creates a hanging lower-body shape absent from the source pose.",
  "smallest_repair": "Repose only the large outlined wing so it folds back close along the rightward body in the source's compact resting position; retain its angular original contour and the existing head, body, and leg drawing.",
  "must_not_be_lost": "The original doodle's spare charcoal line, irregular polygonal head, long pointed body, angular wing outline, and distinctly bent feet; also preserve the current insect scale, placement, left-facing direction, and descending skin boundary.",
  "normal_speed_playback_occurred": false,
  "playback_statement": "Actual normal-speed playback did not occur. This verdict uses direct viewing of source-inspection.jpg, design.png, and all eight paired source and key images. It does not approve animation timing, continuous source pose fidelity, or motion quality. Decoded frames would not constitute playback approval."
}