{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":[],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","trace_fidelity"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"784aab13b4ff12998315c57bbee077f9f0cf11246ca6e0e833f431727143f58f","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"add_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v1/"],"before_refs":["design.png"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"The most prominent crest is assigned to key three instead of the early source impact phase.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original horizontal scribble bundle","Distinctive rightward pointed convergence","Building-and-surf interpretation of the selected source"],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"trace_fidelity","status":"unknown"}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":null,"revision":"hurricane-v1","source":{"identity":"83e2cd5e-159b-57e5-b374-72233abf89ce","interval":{"end":34.2008675342,"start":31.1311311311,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","sequence":1}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["trace_fidelity"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:trace_fidelity"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"a11c8633b71aa2e43bbfc2c23c7102e90c4236e87c82d53a695c81c365c09c09","input":{"action":{"details":"Six proposed still keys; one bounded repair per critique. No motion or model training.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["keys/revisions/v2/"],"before_refs":["reviews/blind-v1.json"],"claims":["drawing"],"critic":{"gap":"The required water-against-building action has no readable fixed impact boundary or impact-to-recession change.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Keep the exact abstract angular scribble character and horizontal water direction.","Keep the dense right-side convergence and long loose left-running strokes.","Do not introduce a funnel, spiral cyclone symbol, shading, or realistic wave rendering."],"scope":["drawing_identity","still_source_poses"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["reviews/blind-v2.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["tests.json"],"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["keys/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum recall; parts_kept must equal1 per key","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"fail","unit":"fraction","value":0.9326781881847961}],"observation_refs":["source.json","design.json"],"parent":"hurricane-v1","revision":"hurricane-v2","source":{"identity":"83e2cd5e-159b-57e5-b374-72233abf89ce","interval":{"end":34.2008675342,"start":31.1311311311,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"784aab13b4ff12998315c57bbee077f9f0cf11246ca6e0e833f431727143f58f","sequence":2}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["trace_fidelity"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","mask_fit","normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:trace_fidelity"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"13e8829e8efa3e0ffd8b37b99cb882c38d3109e93757120608250757901f94c7","input":{"action":{"details":"Assemble original seven strokes over source-keyed crest envelope and fixed building geometry with measured roof translation. No cyclone or particle correspondence claimed.","type":"change_layer"},"after_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v1/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["keys/key-01.png"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Late water strokes appear detached from the fixed building by a clean pale band.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Original seven-stroke silhouette and pointed convergence","Building composition","Early impact-to-recession change"],"scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v1.json","integrated/traced.json","integrated/video-validation.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum raster trace recall, every significant ink piece retained","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"fail","unit":"fraction","value":0.9443694073949013},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"mask_fit","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/video-validation.json"],"name":"video_decode","status":"pass","unit":"frames","value":74}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg","integrated/design.png"],"parent":"hurricane-v2","revision":"hurricane-integrated-v1","source":{"identity":"83e2cd5e-159b-57e5-b374-72233abf89ce","interval":{"end":34.2008675342,"start":31.1311311311,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"a11c8633b71aa2e43bbfc2c23c7102e90c4236e87c82d53a695c81c365c09c09","sequence":3}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["trace_fidelity"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","mask_fit","normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:trace_fidelity"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"3b46d0e5529e3800fff4f6118cfbd20eeaf38cc5db2303163ce6327da4c12d74","input":{"action":{"details":"Bounded repair: existing upper water envelope maintains contact with fixed building base after early surge; same seven original strokes.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v2/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["integrated/revisions/v1/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v1/comparison.mp4"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Early left impact reads as a gently raised surface rather than upward burst against wall.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Angular seven-stroke doodle identity","Building framing"],"scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v2.json","integrated/revisions/v2/traced.json","integrated/revisions/v2/video-validation.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum raster trace recall, every significant ink piece retained","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"fail","unit":"fraction","value":0.9450735169849586},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"mask_fit","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/video-validation.json"],"name":"video_decode","status":"pass","unit":"frames","value":74}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg","integrated/design.png"],"parent":"hurricane-integrated-v1","revision":"hurricane-integrated-v2","source":{"identity":"83e2cd5e-159b-57e5-b374-72233abf89ce","interval":{"end":34.2008675342,"start":31.1311311311,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"13e8829e8efa3e0ffd8b37b99cb882c38d3109e93757120608250757901f94c7","sequence":4}
{"decision":{"preference_constraint_vector":{"compared_playback":null,"critic_scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"critic_verdict":"bar_not_met","drawing_identity_preserved":true,"failed_constraints":["trace_fidelity"],"independent_critic":true,"runtime_cost":null,"source_event_preserved":false,"unknown_constraints":["recognition_classifier","mask_fit","normal_speed_playback"]},"reasons":["source_event_preserved=false","constraint_failed:trace_fidelity"],"status":"rejected","train_eligible":false},"id":"ebedc0a7f1ada0574004a0dbe6e4848388b22364a151c1e30c29d01fb79a6852","input":{"action":{"details":"Final bounded repair: lift and steepen existing upper-left strokes at first two impact keys, settling to existing low rear edge by key3; preserve original seven paths. Stop after three blind rounds.","type":"redraw_key"},"after_refs":["integrated/shot.json","integrated/comparison.mp4"],"before_refs":["integrated/revisions/v2/shot.json","integrated/revisions/v2/comparison.mp4"],"claims":["drawing","motion"],"critic":{"gap":"Continuing foreground surge is underrepresented in the later keys.","independent":true,"protected_strengths":["Keep the original doodle's recognizable angular overlapping stroke construction and the stable, restrained building composition; do not add a new water style or replace the doodle."],"scope":["drawing_identity","source_composition","source_event"],"verdict":"bar_not_met"},"drawing_identity_preserved":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/review-v3.json","integrated/traced.json","integrated/video-validation.json"],"measured_tests":[{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/traced.json"],"metric":"minimum raster trace recall, every significant ink piece retained","name":"trace_fidelity","status":"fail","unit":"fraction","value":0.9514354478253395},{"constraint":true,"name":"recognition_classifier","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"mask_fit","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"name":"normal_speed_playback","status":"unknown"},{"constraint":true,"evidence_refs":["integrated/video-validation.json"],"name":"video_decode","status":"pass","unit":"frames","value":74}],"observation_refs":["source.json","integrated/source-contact-sheet.jpg","integrated/design.png"],"parent":"hurricane-integrated-v2","revision":"hurricane-integrated-v3","source":{"identity":"83e2cd5e-159b-57e5-b374-72233abf89ce","interval":{"end":34.2008675342,"start":31.1311311311,"unit":"seconds"}},"source_event_preserved":false,"train_eligible":false},"previous_hash":"3b46d0e5529e3800fff4f6118cfbd20eeaf38cc5db2303163ce6327da4c12d74","sequence":5}