{
  "review_type": "independent blind still-key review",
  "revision": "v1",
  "motion_approval": false,
  "scope": "Only design.png, first six tiles of keys/revisions/board-v1.png, selected source 16-frame sheet, and selected source six-key sheet where present. No builder notes, prior critiques, or tests inspected.",
  "inspection_method": "Actual view_image inspection of every listed image.",
  "subject": "flying-saucer",
  "bar": "met",
  "identity": "met",
  "source_pose_mechanics": "met",
  "confidence": "medium-high",
  "clip_relative_interval_seconds": [
    2.335669,
    4.537871
  ],
  "reference_indices_1_based": [
    3,
    4,
    5,
    6,
    13,
    14
  ],
  "evidence": [
    "The asymmetric shallow rim, low irregular dome, dome/rim break and sparse surface marks remain recognizable in every key after the design is tilted nearly upright.",
    "The keys maintain the source aeroshell-like near-edge-on attitude with the dome to the right and modest attitude/position variation, transferring that movement vocabulary onto the chosen doodle."
  ],
  "biggest_gap": null,
  "smallest_repair": null,
  "must_not_be_lost": [
    "The exact lopsided rim, uneven dome and small dome/rim gap.",
    "The very sparse dash/speck surface marks and plain unfilled linework.",
    "The upright banked pose family from the NASA CGI source without redesigning the doodle into a realistic aeroshell."
  ],
  "source_note": "Reviewed as movement transfer from NASA CGI aeroshell imagery, not as a claim about physical UFO motion. The selected endpoint indices 13-14 precede the conspicuous trailing deployment in indices 15-16; no tether or parachute addition is required here.",
  "inspected_images": [
    "design.png",
    "keys/revisions/board-v1.png",
    "source-review/selected/f3a1f7f8-5ab6-5e91-8e07-bce434ee536c-16frames.jpg"
  ]
}