{
  "revision": "V02",
  "title": "IN DIFFERENT HANDS",
  "duration": 35,
  "paired_sequence_duration": 30,
  "layout": "720x1248 portrait; full-frame top/bottom panels; context captions",
  "pairs": [
    {
      "timeline_in": 0,
      "timeline_out": 14.0,
      "relation": "Food handled and transferred",
      "difference": "Cook lifts the plate and exits; depositor continues repeated delivery. This is not proof of continuous operation outside the excerpt.",
      "hold_seconds": 0.0,
      "panels": [
        {
          "position": "top",
          "source_title": "Toute La Bande, Episode 9: Bricolage",
          "source_year": 1970,
          "clip_id": "d2156bef-8405-5b07-909f-462b21b6777e",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/c0b50803-2677-5866-90a3-0dee42b7ef04/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/d2156bef-8405-5b07-909f-462b21b6777e.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/d2156bef-8405-5b07-909f-462b21b6777e.mp4",
          "local_file": "film56/forage/336.mp4",
          "clip_in": 8.72,
          "clip_out": 22.72,
          "source_in": 767.712,
          "source_out": 781.712,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              0
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 0.0,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        },
        {
          "position": "bottom",
          "source_title": "Great American Chocolate Factory, The",
          "source_year": null,
          "clip_id": "b63bf343-513d-5e64-80b3-32360ca9d164",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/c2ba49aa-1836-59d8-b476-8612bbbf6b71/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/b63bf343-513d-5e64-80b3-32360ca9d164.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/b63bf343-513d-5e64-80b3-32360ca9d164.mp4",
          "local_file": "sources56/allways/forage/45.mp4",
          "clip_in": 0,
          "clip_out": 14.0,
          "source_in": 1364.63,
          "source_out": 1378.63,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              624
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 0.0,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "timeline_in": 14.0,
      "timeline_out": 20.8,
      "relation": "A person attends to appearance through hand gestures",
      "difference": "Self-directed touches to collar/chin versus a barber working on a child. Neither source proves consent or an emotional state.",
      "hold_seconds": 0.0,
      "panels": [
        {
          "position": "top",
          "source_title": "Health: Your Posture",
          "source_year": 1953,
          "clip_id": "73170844-4c3b-53c8-896c-8cafd663a85f",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/be669207-bc20-57aa-be22-7635cde55771/clips/73170844-4c3b-53c8-896c-8cafd663a85f/source-clip.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/73170844-4c3b-53c8-896c-8cafd663a85f.mp4",
          "local_file": "film56/forage/177.mp4",
          "clip_in": 0,
          "clip_out": 6.8,
          "source_in": 174.841,
          "source_out": 181.641,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              0
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 0.0,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        },
        {
          "position": "bottom",
          "source_title": "Barbers",
          "source_year": 1959,
          "clip_id": "c015a7f0-270a-5dc6-9f43-9f16e4237938",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/da417ab1-290b-521f-be27-b2e8f50590d4/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/c015a7f0-270a-5dc6-9f43-9f16e4237938.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/c015a7f0-270a-5dc6-9f43-9f16e4237938.mp4",
          "local_file": "film56/forage/310.mp4",
          "clip_in": 8.4,
          "clip_out": 15.2,
          "source_in": 480.038,
          "source_out": 486.838,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              624
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 0.0,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "timeline_in": 20.8,
      "timeline_out": 30.0,
      "relation": "Hands demonstrating optical apparatus",
      "difference": "One fitting is covered; the other apparatus remains exposed to manual demonstration. The white object is a glove, not autonomous machine output.",
      "hold_seconds": 3.72,
      "panels": [
        {
          "position": "top",
          "source_title": "Key to Our Horizons",
          "source_year": 1952,
          "clip_id": "7102b861-3ff9-5305-a672-ee93edc49815",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/d838fe71-8556-5f54-82e4-b2689687b511/v3-ffmpeg-openclip-1/clips/7102b861-3ff9-5305-a672-ee93edc49815.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/7102b861-3ff9-5305-a672-ee93edc49815.mp4",
          "local_file": "sources56/allways/step02/176.mp4",
          "clip_in": 5.8,
          "clip_out": 11.28,
          "source_in": 56.084,
          "source_out": 61.564,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              0
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 3.72,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        },
        {
          "position": "bottom",
          "source_title": "RCA 16mm Sound Projector, The",
          "source_year": 1958,
          "clip_id": "a134989d-5295-5292-ac58-db9d4fa601cb",
          "source_url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/rca-16mm-sound-projector-the/clips/0000316716-0000338271.mp4",
          "cached_url": "https://hartswf0.github.io/cineosis-lab/lab/clips/a134989d-5295-5292-ac58-db9d4fa601cb.mp4",
          "local_file": "sources56/allways/forage/41.mp4",
          "clip_in": 15.4,
          "clip_out": 20.88,
          "source_in": 332.116,
          "source_out": 337.596,
          "rights": "Unverified",
          "transform": {
            "crop": "none",
            "aspect": "preserved full source",
            "fit_box": [
              720,
              540
            ],
            "output_position": [
              0,
              624
            ],
            "speed": 1.0,
            "mirror": false,
            "editorial_freeze_seconds": 3.72,
            "original_audio": "omitted"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "sequential_comparison": "Same windows and editorial holds, top then bottom per pair; 60 seconds, silent control.",
  "sound": "Original panned instrumental stems. Source audio omitted; no claim of recorded room ambience.",
  "adaptation": "Archive-led adaptation of SCION 056. The chair/knot proof and proposed 50-second comparison are not literally reproduced. This paired study runs 30s plus 5s closing title.",
  "independent_review": {
    "baseline": "FAIL; critic056/baseline_report.txt",
    "current": [
      {
        "critic": "critic056",
        "verdict": "PASS under narrowed visible-action claims",
        "report": "critic056/v02_report.txt",
        "method": "Whole paired film at 4fps; whole sequential control at 2fps; mobile still."
      },
      {
        "critic": "critic056_fresh",
        "verdict": "PASS; final pair weaker",
        "report": "critic056_fresh/report.txt",
        "method": "120 ordered4fps samples plus overview/end samples and mobile stills; no builder reports consulted."
      }
    ],
    "scope": "Visual pairing only; neither critic auditioned audio or native real-time playback. Closing title excluded.",
    "full_audiovisual_acceptance": "not assessed",
    "remaining_weakness": "Final upper apparatus lacks wider operator/context; its exact identity is not settled by the image. Cover placement versus an enclosed-control reading differed across critics; no switching-on or machine-autonomy claim is supported."
  }
}