{
 "slug": "kinetic",
 "title": "KINETIC",
 "state": "proof in progress",
 "summary": "Three kinds of work (a piston being fitted, a mallet and wedge, a tire-bead machine) share seven seconds of one sung work verse, then it breaks. A refinery worker, a man waiting beside hot rail in Belo Horizonte, a complete interval at a machine, and a hand that stops.",
 "video": {
  "src": "kinetic.mp4",
  "poster": "poster.jpg",
  "duration": 63.68,
  "width": 800,
  "height": 600,
  "card": "ends with a 5 s card naming every source"
 },
 "searches": [
  {
   "q": "worker's hands repeating on assembly line",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-worker-s-hands-repeating-on-assembly-line-ed75.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "woman at a sewing machine in a garment factory",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-woman-at-a-sewing-machine-in-a-garment-factory-b32a.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a worker oils a machine, maintenance",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-worker-oils-a-machine-maintenance-337e.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "repairman fixes broken down machine",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-repairman-fixes-broken-down-machine-831d.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "workers eating lunch on break in factory",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-workers-eating-lunch-on-break-in-factory-1c10.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "workers wait at a factory gate",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-workers-wait-at-a-factory-gate-f7c3.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a blacksmith hammering at the anvil",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-blacksmith-hammering-at-the-anvil-d5f6.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a whistle blows, workers stop and go home",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-whistle-blows-workers-stop-and-go-home-c9f7.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a machine slows and stops",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-machine-slows-and-stops-b244.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "rows of typists typing in an office",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-rows-of-typists-typing-in-an-office-8316.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "shoveling coal into a furnace",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-shoveling-coal-into-a-furnace-8d9b.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "woman ironing at home",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-woman-ironing-at-home-6170.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a man waiting beside a stopped conveyor belt",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-man-waiting-beside-a-stopped-conveyor-belt-07e3.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "loom weaving mill woman walks along machines",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-loom-weaving-mill-woman-walks-along-machines-e2ac.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "a mechanic stops the machine and wipes it with a rag",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-a-mechanic-stops-the-machine-and-wipes-it-with-a-rag-f5ca.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "worker sits waiting beside idle machine",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-worker-sits-waiting-beside-idle-machine-6e7f.jpg"
  },
  {
   "q": "machine stops, operator turns off the switch",
   "results": 24,
   "sheet": "img/sheet-machine-stops-operator-turns-off-the-switch-009f.jpg"
  }
 ],
 "looks": [
  {
   "img": "img/strip-13.jpg",
   "clip": 13,
   "label": "#13 Master Hands (Part III) (1936)",
   "used": [
    1,
    6,
    12
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-49.jpg",
   "clip": 49,
   "label": "#49 Master Hands (undated)",
   "used": [
    10,
    14
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-49_20-22.jpg",
   "clip": 49,
   "label": "#49 Master Hands (undated)",
   "used": [
    10,
    14
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-57.jpg",
   "clip": 57,
   "label": "#57 Master Hands (undated)",
   "used": [],
   "in_cut": false
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-61.jpg",
   "clip": 61,
   "label": "#61 Twenty-Four Hours of Progress (Part II) (1950)",
   "used": [
    9
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-62.jpg",
   "clip": 62,
   "label": "#62 Mental Hospital (1953)",
   "used": [],
   "in_cut": false
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-143.jpg",
   "clip": 143,
   "label": "#143 Kentucky Pioneers (1941)",
   "used": [
    2,
    5,
    13
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-143_1-3.jpg",
   "clip": 143,
   "label": "#143 Kentucky Pioneers (1941)",
   "used": [
    2,
    5,
    13
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-155.jpg",
   "clip": 155,
   "label": "#155 It Takes Everybody to Build This Land (1951)",
   "used": [
    4,
    8
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-155_24-36.jpg",
   "clip": 155,
   "label": "#155 It Takes Everybody to Build This Land (1951)",
   "used": [
    4,
    8
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-191.jpg",
   "clip": 191,
   "label": "#191 How Textile Mills Are Modernizing (1948)",
   "used": [],
   "in_cut": false
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-194.jpg",
   "clip": 194,
   "label": "#194 Under The Tread (1934)",
   "used": [
    3,
    7
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-206.jpg",
   "clip": 206,
   "label": "#206 South Dakota Saga (Part I) (1940)",
   "used": [],
   "in_cut": false
  },
  {
   "img": "img/strip-282.jpg",
   "clip": 282,
   "label": "#282 Belo Horizonte (1949)",
   "used": [
    11
   ],
   "in_cut": true
  }
 ],
 "shots": [
  {
   "position": 1,
   "at": 0.0,
   "dur": 5.208,
   "source": "Master Hands (Part III)",
   "year": 1936,
   "slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7",
   "clip": "80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156",
   "source_in": 119.486,
   "source_out": 124.686,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "process one, tight: piston rings seated by hand, 1936, its own factory score. Tight on purpose; the man comes back later.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/d981bcb7-0407-51be-8672-b672662d1d72/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156.mp4",
   "clip_start": 119.286,
   "source_slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7"
  },
  {
   "position": 2,
   "at": 5.208,
   "dur": 3.917,
   "source": "Kentucky Pioneers",
   "year": 1941,
   "slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6",
   "clip": "e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d",
   "source_in": 311.143,
   "source_out": 315.043,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "process two: mallet and stool, a 1941 re-enactment of frontier work, its narrator kept.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/061890c6-2a80-5f9d-aa23-5a1208411763/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d.mp4",
   "clip_start": 310.143,
   "source_slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6"
  },
  {
   "position": 3,
   "at": 9.125,
   "dur": 8.292,
   "source": "Under The Tread",
   "year": 1934,
   "slug": "under-the-tread-1d8e5b27",
   "clip": "b5caf843-8690-513d-87cc-2123826944ec",
   "source_in": 123.468,
   "source_out": 131.768,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "process three, a woman at a tire-bead machine, 1934, reaching over and over.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/1d8e5b27-a530-57b5-b9ef-794127ce4700/v5-windowed-clip-split-1/clips/b5caf843-8690-513d-87cc-2123826944ec.mp4",
   "clip_start": 112.868,
   "source_slug": "under-the-tread-1d8e5b27"
  },
  {
   "position": 4,
   "at": 17.417,
   "dur": 2.208,
   "source": "It Takes Everybody to Build This Land",
   "year": 1951,
   "slug": "it-takes-everybody-to-build-this-land-7d7a4c15",
   "clip": "f3236d2f-e8df-5772-a34b-9d31d2132ed6",
   "source_in": 566.411,
   "source_out": 568.611,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "coordination begins: a sung work verse from a 1951 film takes over. With a mallet in his hand.",
   "sound_from": [
    {
     "source": "It Takes Everybody to Build This Land",
     "year": 1951,
     "source_in": 566.411,
     "source_out": 573.711
    }
   ],
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/7d7a4c15-0e80-5f45-b477-e2f874a70e09/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/f3236d2f-e8df-5772-a34b-9d31d2132ed6.mp4",
   "clip_start": 544.411,
   "source_slug": "it-takes-everybody-to-build-this-land-7d7a4c15"
  },
  {
   "position": 5,
   "at": 19.625,
   "dur": 1.292,
   "source": "Kentucky Pioneers",
   "year": 1941,
   "slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6",
   "clip": "e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d",
   "source_in": 311.243,
   "source_out": 312.543,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "cut on the sung beat.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/061890c6-2a80-5f9d-aa23-5a1208411763/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d.mp4",
   "clip_start": 310.143,
   "source_slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6"
  },
  {
   "position": 6,
   "at": 20.917,
   "dur": 1.542,
   "source": "Master Hands (Part III)",
   "year": 1936,
   "slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7",
   "clip": "80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156",
   "source_in": 119.886,
   "source_out": 121.436,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "cut on the sung beat: these hands are not holding a mallet, and the song does not know that.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/d981bcb7-0407-51be-8672-b672662d1d72/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156.mp4",
   "clip_start": 119.286,
   "source_slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7"
  },
  {
   "position": 7,
   "at": 22.458,
   "dur": 1.0,
   "source": "Under The Tread",
   "year": 1934,
   "slug": "under-the-tread-1d8e5b27",
   "clip": "b5caf843-8690-513d-87cc-2123826944ec",
   "source_in": 124.068,
   "source_out": 125.068,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "cut on the sung beat; the tire worker is also inside the carpenter's song for one second.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/1d8e5b27-a530-57b5-b9ef-794127ce4700/v5-windowed-clip-split-1/clips/b5caf843-8690-513d-87cc-2123826944ec.mp4",
   "clip_start": 112.868,
   "source_slug": "under-the-tread-1d8e5b27"
  },
  {
   "position": 8,
   "at": 23.458,
   "dur": 1.292,
   "source": "It Takes Everybody to Build This Land",
   "year": 1951,
   "slug": "it-takes-everybody-to-build-this-land-7d7a4c15",
   "clip": "f3236d2f-e8df-5772-a34b-9d31d2132ed6",
   "source_in": 571.411,
   "source_out": 572.711,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "back to the mallet as the verse ends. Coordination lasts seven seconds and is never repeated.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/7d7a4c15-0e80-5f45-b477-e2f874a70e09/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/f3236d2f-e8df-5772-a34b-9d31d2132ed6.mp4",
   "clip_start": 544.411,
   "source_slug": "it-takes-everybody-to-build-this-land-7d7a4c15"
  },
  {
   "position": 9,
   "at": 24.75,
   "dur": 5.5,
   "source": "Twenty-Four Hours of Progress (Part II)",
   "year": 1950,
   "slug": "twenty-four-hours-of-progress-part-ii-8aae7e31",
   "clip": "a09d4b6e-2269-5b6b-90e1-3c4ad22e8a35",
   "source_in": 313.641,
   "source_out": 319.141,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "coordination broken by a hard cut. A refinery worker wipes his hands and holds a valve wheel, in his own time, at normal speed, with his film's voice.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/8aae7e31-e540-54db-81ed-65d4a092fbf8/v3-ffmpeg-openclip-1/clips/a09d4b6e-2269-5b6b-90e1-3c4ad22e8a35.mp4",
   "clip_start": 308.141,
   "source_slug": "twenty-four-hours-of-progress-part-ii-8aae7e31"
  },
  {
   "position": 10,
   "at": 30.25,
   "dur": 10.792,
   "source": "Master Hands",
   "year": null,
   "slug": "master-hands",
   "clip": "674f06f7-01f5-5e85-8e0b-4ff25256c930",
   "source_in": 793.533,
   "source_out": 804.333,
   "transforms": [
    "crop=1440:1080"
   ],
   "why": "the interval, whole and at normal speed: a man looks into a machine, then reaches up into it. Nothing is produced.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/master-hands/clips/0000789333-0000811625.mp4",
   "clip_start": 789.333,
   "source_slug": "master-hands"
  },
  {
   "position": 11,
   "at": 41.042,
   "dur": 5.708,
   "source": "Belo Horizonte",
   "year": 1949,
   "slug": "belo-horizonte-144b2ce5",
   "clip": "c3e88719-d14e-5aaf-b9c3-fe7ecd433801",
   "source_in": 366.73,
   "source_out": 372.43,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "waiting: a man stands while hot rail runs past him. Belo Horizonte, 1949, not Detroit, and his narrator says so.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/144b2ce5-bf8e-5685-a46b-5d1dcf6accb7/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/c3e88719-d14e-5aaf-b9c3-fe7ecd433801.mp4",
   "clip_start": 363.03,
   "source_slug": "belo-horizonte-144b2ce5"
  },
  {
   "position": 12,
   "at": 46.75,
   "dur": 5.917,
   "source": "Master Hands (Part III)",
   "year": 1936,
   "slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7",
   "clip": "80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156",
   "source_in": 126.786,
   "source_out": 132.686,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "return to process one, wider: there was a face, and another man's arm, the whole time.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/d981bcb7-0407-51be-8672-b672662d1d72/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/80ee2c3e-0fed-56f5-8ff9-8c4b833ae156.mp4",
   "clip_start": 119.286,
   "source_slug": "master-hands-part-iii-d981bcb7"
  },
  {
   "position": 13,
   "at": 52.667,
   "dur": 2.167,
   "source": "Kentucky Pioneers",
   "year": 1941,
   "slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6",
   "clip": "e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d",
   "source_in": 317.143,
   "source_out": 319.293,
   "transforms": [],
   "why": "end: the old man reaches away from the block and the mallet is down.",
   "sound_from": [
    {
     "source": "Kentucky Pioneers",
     "year": 1941,
     "source_in": 318.343,
     "source_out": 319.293
    }
   ],
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/061890c6-2a80-5f9d-aa23-5a1208411763/v4-conditional-luna-1/clips/e78f7433-8a1b-597e-9c02-eee50ac9b97d.mp4",
   "clip_start": 310.143,
   "source_slug": "kentucky-pioneers-061890c6"
  },
  {
   "position": 14,
   "at": 54.833,
   "dur": 3.792,
   "source": "Master Hands",
   "year": null,
   "slug": "master-hands",
   "clip": "674f06f7-01f5-5e85-8e0b-4ff25256c930",
   "source_in": 809.933,
   "source_out": 811.533,
   "transforms": [
    "crop=1440:1080",
    "last frame held 2.2s"
   ],
   "why": "end: a hand, stopped. Last frame held.",
   "url": "https://pub-075ff01374c04555b51c9bc50f258b42.r2.dev/sources/master-hands/clips/0000789333-0000811625.mp4",
   "clip_start": 789.333,
   "source_slug": "master-hands"
  }
 ],
 "reel": "img/reel.jpg",
 "reviews": [
  {
   "round": 1,
   "who": "independent critic (fresh Claude Sonnet 5.5 agent)",
   "verdict": "reference stronger",
   "text": "VERDICT: reference stronger (leaning inconclusive on sound; I cannot hear the film, so the \"original sound phrase\" and any coordination by sound go unjudged).\n\nNoticed before the brief: at 0:17-0:24 the film cuts between a log and a mallet (0:17-0:19, 0:23-0:24), the mallet worker (0:20) and the engine-block hand (0:21). Then at 0:22 it cuts back to the woman at the wheel, with the cuts landing on the narration \"mallet... carpenter\". It reads as one repeated beat, but the transcript's talk of tires, stools and \"oil business\" does not describe what the frames show (engine blocks, a furnace). That mismatch is probably recogniser error in the hiss, so I treat it as unreliable.\n\nLargest gap: the brief wants an interruption kept at normal speed, and I see none. The sheet shows only continuous labor across 44s. The \"interruption\" at 0:17-0:19 is a static log with no worker. It is an insert, not a maintenance interval, and it lasts about 3 seconds. The target is 90s and this is 44s. The loudness data shows nothing that reads as a coordination phrase, and a drop to -45.9 dB at 42s suggests an abrupt end. The ending at 0:42-0:43 is the mallet worker again, still working. Nothing stops, so the brief's end condition is unmet.\n\nRepairs:\n1. 0:17-0:19: replace the log insert with one complete waiting or maintenance shot of 6s or more at real speed. Check that a worker is visibly idle or tending the machine.\n2. 0:42-0:43: end on a stopped hand or machine. Check that the last frame shows no motion.\n3. 0:25-0:35: add one wide contextual shot. Check that it shows what the close crop at 0:09-0:16 left out.\n\nProtect: the 0:36-0:41 engine-block sequence with the 0:42 return to the mallet worker. It shows a changed framing on return.",
   "builder_note": "True: nothing in the first cut was an interval. A whole 10.8 s interval from Master Hands was added, and the film now ends on a stopped hand.",
   "packet": {
    "note": "This round's packet images were overwritten when the next round's packet was built, so they are not kept."
   }
  },
  {
   "round": 2,
   "who": "independent critic (fresh Claude Sonnet 5.5 agent)",
   "verdict": "reference stronger",
   "text": "VERDICT: reference stronger (a pass is not earned). I cannot hear the film; the sound phrase and any rhythm coordination are unjudged. Speech recognition in the hiss is partly unreliable.\n\nNoticed before the brief: 17.1-18.3 is a hard cut to a static wood block on a stump. By 19.6 it returns to the mallet worker from 4.9-7.3, so the film recycles the same clips. The narration is also mismatched. \"Carpenter... stool\" (5.7-9.1) plays over a woman at a machine, and \"tire... flipper\" (9.1-17.2) plays over the same woman. The ASR lines are loose, but they do not match the pictures.\n\nLargest gap: there are no three distinct processes with an established repeated movement. Cylinder-block hands, the mallet worker, the woman at the wheel, the hard-hat worker, the machine operator and the furnace all get one or two brief appearances. No beat is visibly repeated, and no maintenance or waiting interval appears (30.5-40.3 is a continuous task). There is no return that reveals excluded framing. The ending at 54.9-57.4 is a static hand close-up, not a worker or machine stopping.\n\nRepairs:\n1. Cut the sheet to three processes, with 3 or more visible repetitions each by 0-30s. Check: each process appears in at least 3 shots, with the same action visible in each.\n2. Hold one maintenance or wait shot unbroken for 4s or more at normal speed, around 30.5-40.3. Check: one continuous shot with no cut and a visible pause in the work.\n3. Replace 54.9-57.4 with a wider re-frame of the 4.9-7.3 mallet worker, ending on the mallet stopping. Check: the frame is wider than at 4.9 and shows the mallet at rest.\n\nStrength to protect: the high-contrast black-and-white texture and the hands-and-machinery close-ups (0-3.7, 46.4-51.3) read clearly as labor.",
   "builder_note": "The critic wants three processes, each with at least three visible repetitions. The film shows each process in one or two short shots; that is below the brief and was not repaired.",
   "packet": {
    "sheet": "img/critic-r2-sheet.jpg",
    "transcript": "critic/transcript-r2.txt",
    "note": "the cut after the interval shot and the stopped-hand ending were added"
   }
  }
 ],
 "repairs": [
  "Added the interval at the machine.",
  "Replaced the ending with a stopped hand, last frame held."
 ],
 "notes": {
  "worked": [
   "The verse comes from a 1951 film; each process is cut on its beat, and the coordination is allowed to last only seven seconds.",
   "The interval (a man looks into a machine, then reaches into it) runs 10.8 s at normal speed."
  ],
  "failed": [
   "The first cut had no interval at all.",
   "The critic counts the three processes as one or two short shots each, not repeated movements; that is below the brief.",
   "59 s against 90 s."
  ],
  "open": [
   "Three or more visible repetitions of each process before they are coordinated.",
   "A wide contextual shot of what the close crops leave out."
  ]
 },
 "extras": [],
 "files": [
  {
   "path": "edl.json",
   "label": "edit list: every in, out, gain and reason, as written"
  },
  {
   "path": "ledger.json",
   "label": "ledger: each shot traced to its source seconds"
  },
  {
   "path": "brief.md",
   "label": "the brief the critic received"
  }
 ]
}