{ "slug": "BROLL_12_Planimetric", "version": "v2", "series": "BROLL_OF_CIVILIZATION", "kicker": "B-ROLL OF CIVILIZATION 12 \u00b7 SCION 086 + 085 + 089", "title": "PLANIMETRIC", "subtitle": "Held frames \u2014 locked-off depth planes where background routine and deviation meet", "scion_id": 86, "supporting_scions": [ 85, 89 ], "lineage": "Primary: SCION 086 (Songs from the Second Floor) \u00b7 Supporting: SCION 085 (Jeanne Dielman), SCION 089 (Wes Anderson / Yeoman)", "theorem": "Select fixed, planimetric views of rooms and workspaces with practical activities at different depths. Hold the frame while foreground and background tasks interact and a small route change alters the arrangement, without cutting to a rescuing close-up.", "boundary_note": "Static, centered, and planimetric are distinct constraints; original archival camera behavior is preserved without artificial pan-and-scan.", "critic_tribunal": { "film_id": "BROLL_12_Planimetric", "scion_id": 86, "critic_role": "Independent tableau critic", "v1_verdict": "repair_required", "v1_defect_timecodes": [ "Seg #02 (t=03.50s-14.00s): `8d2b2cbb` (`Long Distance`, 1941) cuts internally at t=05.5s from switchboard operators to 1940s trucks on a highway.", "Seg #05 (t=32.00s-42.00s): `8d2b2cbb` at in_s=14.0s dissolves across forest linemen, a close-up operator, and a moving bus." ], "largest_gap": "The primary constraint of `PLANIMETRIC`\u2014a sustained, locked-off fixed view of a room without camera movement or cuts\u2014was violated by internal montage cuts in `8d2b2cbb`.", "causal_hypothesis": "`Long Distance` (`8d2b2cbb`) is a promotional montage with cuts every 2-3 seconds.", "falsifiable_repair": "Replace Seg #02 and Seg #05 with Cineosis human-verified locked-off planimetric room shots: `79565922` (`Working Together`, 1951, `10.2s-19.7s` in Seg #02 and `19.7s-28.4s` in Seg #05, showing the same frontal conference room as posture and table geometry shift across time), paired with `3533825c` (`White Ammunition`, 1942 workshop) and `780c159d` (`Success in Business`, `0.5s-10.0s`, locked-off frontal room tableau).", "strength_to_preserve": "Tableau 02 (`3533825c`, `White Ammunition`, 1942) and the locked-off conference room tableau (`79565922`, `Working Together`, 1951).", "v2_verdict": "pass" }, "duration_seconds": 41.5, "video_file": "films/BROLL_12_Planimetric.mp4", "source_count": 3, "sources_summary": [ "79565922 \u00b7 Working Together: A Case History in Labor-Management Cooperation (1951)", "3533825c \u00b7 White Ammunition (1942)", "20cf914f \u00b7 Project Thunderstorm, 05/1947 - 09/1947 (1947)" ], "edl": [ { "seg_idx": 1, "type": "title_card", "title": "PLANIMETRIC", "phase": "OPENING SLATE", "action": "Held frames \u2014 locked-off depth planes where background routine and deviation meet", "start_sec": 0.0, "end_sec": 3.0, "dur_s": 3.0 }, { "type": "shot", "clip_id": "79565922-be19-5b28-8c01-2ffb430ec5da", "source_title": "Working Together: A Case History in Labor-Management Cooperation", "source_year": 1951, "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/working-together-a-case-history-in-labor-management-cooperation-1f8b859c?clip=79565922-be19-5b28-8c01-2ffb430ec5da", "in_s": 10.2, "out_s": 19.2, "dur_s": 9.0, "phase": "TABLEAU 01 \u00b7 LABOR-MANAGEMENT HALL (1951)", "action": "Working Together (1951): Locked-off frontal room view \u2014 foreground note-taking and background wall/window plane held 9.0s", "nearmatch": "LOCKED PLANIMETRIC ROOM \u00b7 HELD 9.0s", "seg_idx": 2, "start_sec": 3.0, "end_sec": 12.0 }, { "type": "shot", "clip_id": "3533825c-f38f-5d05-8be8-83dd995e9680", "source_title": "White Ammunition", "source_year": 1942, "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/white-ammunition-8b2ceba5?clip=3533825c-f38f-5d05-8be8-83dd995e9680", "in_s": 0.2, "out_s": 8.7, "dur_s": 8.5, "phase": "TABLEAU 02 \u00b7 WHITE AMMUNITION WORKSHOP (1942)", "action": "White Ammunition (1942): Frontal workshop plane \u2014 foreground inspection bench and background corridor movement", "nearmatch": "TWO DEPTH PLANES \u00b7 HELD 8.5s", "seg_idx": 3, "start_sec": 12.0, "end_sec": 20.5 }, { "type": "shot", "clip_id": "20cf914f-fcc0-5dc1-9af6-b5fe710b8b96", "source_title": "Project Thunderstorm, 05/1947 - 09/1947", "source_year": 1947, "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/project-thunderstorm-05-1947-09-1947-e8ef7ef6?clip=20cf914f-fcc0-5dc1-9af6-b5fe710b8b96", "in_s": 0.5, "out_s": 9.0, "dur_s": 8.5, "phase": "TABLEAU 03 \u00b7 METEOROLOGICAL WORKROOM TABLEAU (1947)", "action": "Project Thunderstorm (1947): Symmetrical frontal workroom \u2014 foreground drafting table and background staff plane held 8.5s", "nearmatch": "NO RESCUING CLOSE-UP \u00b7 HELD 8.5s", "seg_idx": 4, "start_sec": 20.5, "end_sec": 29.0 }, { "type": "shot", "clip_id": "79565922-be19-5b28-8c01-2ffb430ec5da", "source_title": "Working Together: A Case History in Labor-Management Cooperation", "source_year": 1951, "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/working-together-a-case-history-in-labor-management-cooperation-1f8b859c?clip=79565922-be19-5b28-8c01-2ffb430ec5da", "in_s": 19.2, "out_s": 28.2, "dur_s": 9.0, "phase": "TABLEAU 01 RETURN \u00b7 SHIFTED POSTURE IN THE HELD FRAME (1951)", "action": "Working Together (1951): Returning to the locked conference room as speakers lean and shift the table's social balance", "nearmatch": "CHANGED ARRANGEMENT IN HELD FRAME", "seg_idx": 5, "start_sec": 29.0, "end_sec": 38.0 }, { "seg_idx": 6, "type": "closing_ledger", "title": "SOURCE ATTRIBUTION & BOUNDARY NOTE", "phase": "CLOSING LEDGER", "action": "Static, centered, and planimetric are distinct constraints; original archival camera behavior is preserved without artificial pan-and-scan.", "start_sec": 38.0, "end_sec": 41.5, "dur_s": 3.5 } ] }