{
  "slug": "BROLL_09_Anybody_Anywhere",
  "version": "v2",
  "series": "BROLL_OF_CIVILIZATION",
  "kicker": "B-ROLL OF CIVILIZATION 09 \u00b7 SCION 056 + 099",
  "title": "ANYBODY, ANYWHERE",
  "subtitle": "Lives in parallel \u2014 paired ordinary acts across different decades and rooms",
  "scion_id": 56,
  "supporting_scions": [
    99
  ],
  "lineage": "Primary: SCION 056 (Symmetry) \u00b7 Supporting: SCION 099 (Out My Window)",
  "theorem": "Build a comparison from three pairs of situated recordings. Start with two people preparing a place to sit, let one finish while the other waits, restore a wider contextual view on each side before the next pair, and conclude where resemblance fails at the outcome.",
  "boundary_note": "Parallel presentation does not claim simultaneous recording; explicit years (or undated archival states) and separate stereo sound spaces are preserved.",
  "critic_tribunal": {
    "film_id": "BROLL_09_Anybody_Anywhere",
    "scion_id": 56,
    "critic_role": "Independent comparison critic",
    "v1_verdict": "repair_required",
    "v1_defect_timecodes": [
      "Seg #05 (t=21.00s-29.50s): In Pair 2, `c87ef931` (right panel) cuts across 3 montage shots while `99f04233` (left panel) shows men talking in coats instead of manual bench work.",
      "Seg #06 (t=29.50s-38.00s): In Pair 3, both `c313c355` and `708fb7c2` cut internally near t=36.98s (clip ~8.0s)."
    ],
    "largest_gap": "Pairs 2 and 3 suffer internal montage cuts inside the split-screen panels.",
    "causal_hypothesis": "Unverified internal cuts inside `c87ef931` and past 8.0s in `c313c355` and `708fb7c2`.",
    "falsifiable_repair": "Replace Pair 2 (Seg #05) with human-verified cut-free manual desk/tabletop work clips `3a48bbc4` (`Fundo in Chile`, `0.2s-8.2s`, two people working with plans/tools) vs `9bb420b0` (`Make Art Feel Better`, `1.0s-9.0s`, hands carving wood at table); clamp Pair 3 (Seg #06, `c313c355` vs `708fb7c2`) to `in_a=0.2, in_b=0.2, dur=7.2` so both panels finish cleanly before the 8.0s cut.",
    "strength_to_preserve": "Pair 1 (`c0c5c8e6` vs `98a82cba`) and its two wide contextual restorations (`bb5ffe06` and `4ccd304a`).",
    "v2_verdict": "pass"
  },
  "duration_seconds": 37.42,
  "video_file": "films/BROLL_09_Anybody_Anywhere.mp4",
  "source_count": 8,
  "sources_summary": [
    "c0c5c8e6 \u00b7 The Electric House (1922)",
    "98a82cba \u00b7 How Quiet Helps at School (1953)",
    "bb5ffe06 \u00b7 The Electric House (1922)",
    "4ccd304a \u00b7 Let's Be Good Citizens at School (1953)",
    "3a48bbc4 \u00b7 Fundo in Chile (1949)",
    "9bb420b0 \u00b7 Make Art Feel Better with Billie Bivins: Whittling Wood (2013)",
    "c313c355 \u00b7 Wreckless (1935)",
    "708fb7c2 \u00b7 Astronauts: United States Project Mercury, ca. 1960 (undated)"
  ],
  "edl": [
    {
      "seg_idx": 1,
      "type": "title_card",
      "title": "ANYBODY, ANYWHERE",
      "phase": "OPENING SLATE",
      "action": "Lives in parallel \u2014 paired ordinary acts across different decades and rooms",
      "start_sec": 0.0,
      "end_sec": 3.0,
      "dur_s": 3.0
    },
    {
      "type": "split_shot",
      "clip_a": {
        "id": "c0c5c8e6-917d-5c0a-8e96-2bcd5ebb5ffb",
        "title": "The Electric House",
        "year": 1922,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/the-electric-house-4864a465?clip=c0c5c8e6-917d-5c0a-8e96-2bcd5ebb5ffb"
      },
      "clip_b": {
        "id": "98a82cba-2285-548b-9db7-29b0af3531a5",
        "title": "How Quiet Helps at School",
        "year": 1953,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/how-quiet-helps-at-school?clip=98a82cba-2285-548b-9db7-29b0af3531a5"
      },
      "dur_s": 8.0,
      "phase": "SPLIT COMPARISON",
      "action": "Pair 1 (Preparing a place to sit): 1922 domestic mechanism vs 1953 schoolroom table",
      "nearmatch": "DATES: 1922 vs 1953 \u00b7 UNEQUAL COMPLETION",
      "seg_idx": 2,
      "start_sec": 3.0,
      "end_sec": 11.0
    },
    {
      "type": "shot",
      "clip_id": "bb5ffe06-28d9-56e7-a7af-41909ddce0a9",
      "source_title": "The Electric House",
      "source_year": 1922,
      "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/the-electric-house-4864a465?clip=bb5ffe06-28d9-56e7-a7af-41909ddce0a9",
      "in_s": 0.2,
      "out_s": 4.4,
      "dur_s": 4.2,
      "phase": "WIDE CONTEXT LEFT \u00b7 THE ELECTRIC HOUSE (1922)",
      "action": "Restoring the wider architectural setting of the 1922 house before the second pair",
      "nearmatch": "CONTEXT RESTORED (1922)",
      "seg_idx": 3,
      "start_sec": 11.0,
      "end_sec": 15.2
    },
    {
      "type": "shot",
      "clip_id": "4ccd304a-fe48-5d3e-932d-fa51f6c1e373",
      "source_title": "Let's Be Good Citizens at School",
      "source_year": 1953,
      "source_page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/let-s-be-good-citizens-at-school-caf7c05a?clip=4ccd304a-fe48-5d3e-932d-fa51f6c1e373",
      "in_s": 0.13,
      "out_s": 2.34,
      "dur_s": 3.5,
      "phase": "WIDE CONTEXT RIGHT \u00b7 SCHOOL INTERIOR (1953)",
      "action": "Restoring the wider social classroom setting of 1953 before the second pair",
      "nearmatch": "CONTEXT RESTORED (1953)",
      "seg_idx": 4,
      "start_sec": 15.2,
      "end_sec": 18.7
    },
    {
      "type": "split_shot",
      "clip_a": {
        "id": "3a48bbc4-5fc6-51e8-9958-22c51ab9e758",
        "title": "Fundo in Chile",
        "year": 1949,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/fundo-in-chile-1112adf6?clip=3a48bbc4-5fc6-51e8-9958-22c51ab9e758"
      },
      "clip_b": {
        "id": "9bb420b0-710f-55df-b000-97b394d2005d",
        "title": "Make Art Feel Better with Billie Bivins: Whittling Wood",
        "year": 2013,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/make-art-feel-better-with-billie-bivins-whittling-wood-42fe150b?clip=9bb420b0-710f-55df-b000-97b394d2005d"
      },
      "dur_s": 8.0,
      "phase": "SPLIT COMPARISON",
      "action": "Pair 2 (Hands at a table task): Fundo in Chile (1949) drafting plans vs Make Art Feel Better (1971) carving wood",
      "nearmatch": "DATES: 1949 vs 1971 \u00b7 COLLABORATIVE PLANS vs SOLO CRAFT",
      "seg_idx": 5,
      "start_sec": 18.7,
      "end_sec": 26.7
    },
    {
      "type": "split_shot",
      "clip_a": {
        "id": "c313c355-ead3-597d-b1be-401841bca49e",
        "title": "Wreckless",
        "year": 1935,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/wreckless-a46a460b?clip=c313c355-ead3-597d-b1be-401841bca49e"
      },
      "clip_b": {
        "id": "708fb7c2-1047-5fee-bc58-88b69de119fb",
        "title": "Astronauts: United States Project Mercury, ca. 1960",
        "year": null,
        "page": "https://www.movingimagearchive.com/sources/astronauts-united-states-project-mercury-ca-1960-2fc31a7a?clip=708fb7c2-1047-5fee-bc58-88b69de119fb"
      },
      "dur_s": 7.2,
      "phase": "SPLIT COMPARISON",
      "action": "Pair 3 (Resemblance fails at outcome): Wreckless (1935) courtroom bench vs Astronauts (ca.1960) step-test platform",
      "nearmatch": "DATES: 1935 vs ca.1960 \u00b7 DIVERGENT OUTCOMES",
      "seg_idx": 6,
      "start_sec": 26.7,
      "end_sec": 33.9
    },
    {
      "seg_idx": 7,
      "type": "closing_ledger",
      "title": "SOURCE ATTRIBUTION & BOUNDARY NOTE",
      "phase": "CLOSING LEDGER",
      "action": "Parallel presentation does not claim simultaneous recording; explicit years (or undated archival states) and separate stereo sound spaces are preserved.",
      "start_sec": 33.9,
      "end_sec": 37.4,
      "dur_s": 3.5
    }
  ]
}